Exhaust, diesel fumes foul public schoolyards across Washington state
More than a dozen schools are located in the pollution plume created by traffic on Interstate 5.
More than half a century has elapsed since the Seattle School Board — with nary a raised eyebrow, records indicate — voted to allow one of the nation's biggest and busiest highways to be built cheek-by-jowl with John Marshall Junior High, trading away the school's playground for a larger plot of land nearby.
The John Marshall building beside Interstate 5 near Green Lake was closed for the last few years, but its doors are expected to open again to North Seattle middle schoolers in 2014. Yet now, as in 1958, school board deliberations on the renovation and opening of the school didn’t include a word about the road rushing over the kids' heads, despite a compelling body of evidence dating back decades that air pollution from highways can cause lifelong respiratory problems and asthma attacks and boost school absenteeism.
At least one school board member, Kay Smith-Blum, was alerted to the dangers at John Marshall. Locating a school beside a big road “raises public health concerns,” the director of the Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Unit at the University of Washington said in an email to a concerned parent, which was copied to Smith-Blum. “Limiting children’s exposure to vehicle emissions should be a priority consideration.”
“I do recall seeing a letter from a UW professor/health professional with regard to the John Marshall building potential issues with air quality,” Smith-Blum wrote in an email response to questions from InvestigateWest. She passed the email along to the facilities team, she says. “I am sure those concerns are being addressed/vetted by our staff,” Smith-Blum wrote.
But in fact, 21 months elapsed between the health expert’s September 2011 email and the time Seattle Schools officials, prompted by InvestigateWest’s questions, started looking into the dangers. The school board's decision to reopen John Marshall is just one example of how, when it comes to air pollution near roads, Washington state school policies haven't caught up with the science.
Children spend about a third of their day at school, often during the hours of heaviest traffic. Many schools sit alongside big, busy roads because that’s where land is cheap and bus access is more convenient. Within 500 feet of major roads, traffic pollution — a plume of suspended soot and gases — often carries pollutants at levels considered harmful by air-pollution researchers. A 2008 study found that more than 10 percent of surveyed U.S. schools were located within about 300 feet of highways, the distance within which road pollution is most potent.
A new InvestigateWest analysis found nearly 30 public Washington K-12 schools sit within 500 feet of a major road. Eight of the 30 schools beside highways were built within the past 10 years — after the dangers were well established by scientific research.
An additional 166 schools are located within 500 feet of the state’s heaviest truck routes. The diesel fuel that powers these trucks can produce 100 to 200 times more soot than gasoline engines, and the exhaust is so toxic that the World Health Organization classifies it as a carcinogen.
Yet in Washington, school districts reported that pollution from highways is rarely, if ever, considered in their school siting decisions, or in health strategies for existing schools. Contrast that with California, which a decade ago passed a law requiring that new schools be built at least 500 feet from major roads. At least five other states have similar siting guidelines in place. At existing schools, there are ways to reduce the danger, too: better air filters can help, for example, as can restricting kids’ time outside when traffic is heavy.
Examples of Washington schools near roads abound. In Federal Way, a high school and its open-air football stadium, both opened in 2004, sit less than 500 feet from I-5. The school board vote to buy the large swath of property for the new facilities was unanimous.
In Vancouver, when the district raised a new elementary school in 2004 on property that’s hosted a schoolhouse since the 1800s, an environmental review didn’t mention the health effects from the interstate that had appeared a stone’s throw from the property line.
“Because the school is not fronting the freeway, it didn’t seem to present a problem,” said Vancouver Public Schools Assistant Superintendent Todd Horenstein.
And when Seattle Schools in 2012 tapped John Marshall to be brought out of mothballs, the thundering highway suspended over its twin tennis courts wasn’t mentioned in a single school board discussion of the building’s suitability.
“I’ve worked for Seattle schools for 10 years and I’ve never had any conversations on [outdoor] air quality,” said Jennifer Kovach, an assistant principal at Van Asselt Elementary. The school, like five others in Seattle, sits within the pollution plume of I-5.
“Anecdotally, it doesn’t seem like a problem,” Kovach told InvestigateWest in May. “Maybe we’re blissfully ignorant.”
Parent and Biostatistician at the University of Washington
The dangers of vehicle emissions have been known for years: researchers in Europe first made the connection between children’s poor lung function and school-day exposure to traffic in 1993. Ten years later a California Environmental Protection Agency study made a similar leap, finding that kids in San Francisco’s East Bay attending near-road schools were 5 to 8 percent more likely to suffer from bronchitis and asthma.
“The relative risk is small, but when you multiply that hundreds of thousands of kids in California who are exposed to traffic, it ends up being a rather significant effect,” said Bart Ostro, the study’s lead investigator.
Even though kids spend only a slice of their day at school, Ostro says that that time — and where’s it’s spent — is important if only because it’s when parents cede the most control.
“At home, you can reduce exposures by keeping your windows closed during rush hour, having cleaner filters. At school, they’re really subject to whatever the district does,” he said.
Of the roughly 50,000 kids who will attend Seattle schools this fall, nearly 2,000 of those will hit the books in classrooms within 500 feet of I-5. Of those schools, one has an advanced filter to catch the biggest bits of soot — TOPS in Eastlake.
Like John Marshall Junior High, TOPS — formerly Seward Elementary — found itself in the path of I-5 in the late 1950s. The first and second floors were level with the rushing highway and completely unprotected from air pollution until a sound barrier was installed around 2000. That made TOPS a firm “no” for Sooraj Kuttykrishnan when choosing a school for his daughter. Raised in an industrial city in western India, Kuttykrishnan started kindergarten with crippling asthma, terrifying his parents and imperiling the family’s finances with heavy medical bills.
So when choosing where his own daughter would start school, he and his wife Rebecca crossed TOPS off the list.
It didn’t help that Kuttykrishnan, a biostatistician at the University of Washington, had just finished working on a U.S. Environmental Protection Agency-funded study examining the link between traffic pollution and cardiovascular disease. Results showing a firm link between roadway pollution and a higher blood pressure and hardening arteries didn’t ease his worries.
“I’ve seen data measured near freeways. It’s hard to imagine that it wouldn’t be bad,” he said.
The couple even chose to live in a pricey neighborhood in Capitol Hill so that their daughter could attend a school set back farther from roads.
“We just came back over and over to the idea that nine years of 30 hours per week adjacent to a freeway was a huge, huge negative," his wife Rebecca wrote in an email. “In the end, we finally shelled out the money and mortgaged our financial futures,” she wrote, so their daughter could attend a safer school.
Not all parents are as concerned. Johnny Calcagno, a former TOPS parent whose son spent nine years at the school, said that although the school sits almost flush with the highway, the air quality around the school doesn’t seem particularly bad to him.
“It might be attributable to being in Eastlake, maybe it’s the lake air and the exhaust has other outlets,” he said.
Proximity doesn’t necessarily equal risk. Schools uphill from a road often experience less pollution than those downhill. Wind plays a role, as does topography like sound walls and trees and hedges.
Despite the many variables that influence pollution plumes, the more than 40 epidemiological studies measuring traffic’s negative impact on health speak loudly, said Dr. Christine Bae, an associate professor with the University of Washington’s Department of Urban Planning and Design.
“It’s clearly an unhealthy situation,” Bae said.
Bae co-authored a 2006 survey of schools near freeways in Seattle and Portland. She and her co-authors found that the most growth in Seattle during the past decade had occurred within freeway air pollution plumes. For Bae and fellow researcher Alon Bassok, that growth represents a missing link between the health profession and city planners.
“These are bigger land use regulation issues,” Bassok said. “Talk to people who have an impact on this and you’ll find that they’re not aware of it.”
That might be changing. When the interstate first came to John Marshall in 1958, air pollution was a distant notion for the denizens of leafy North Seattle. But 60 years later, the planned re-debut of the school has touched off a low boil among parents and health advocates.
An unsigned email to the district during deliberations about where to put the glut of North Seattle middle schoolers echoed what parents had been debating in blog forums for months.
“Make sure you are prepared to defend J. Marshall as an acceptable permanent site when additional environmental data is published recording negative health impacts of auto traffic near freeways. This will only increase.”
The school district is overhauling John Marshall’s electrical system and completing upgrades on its heating and ventilation system. Currently there are no plans to incorporate heavy-duty air filters or other protective measures to offset air pollution risks.
But, says district spokesperson Teresa Wippel, “We do have some time, with John Marshall. There aren’t kids there yet.”
Maria Renninger is the John Marshall parent who contacted UW’s experts on air pollution’s effects on kids, prompting the email from Catherine Carr, head of the Northwest Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Unit — the email copied to Smith-Blum, the school board member. Renninger said she never received a response.
“We’re talking about where to put children who can’t speak for themselves,” Renninger said. “Parents are looking to the district and thinking, ‘They wouldn’t put kids there if there was problem, there must be laws.’ But the truth is there aren’t.”
by Olivia Henry and Kate Martin
by Kate Martin
By Chris Ingalls, KING 5
by Olivia Henry and Kate Martin
by InvestigateWest Staff
By Kate Martin
By Chris Ingalls, KING 5
by InvestigateWest Staff
by Olivia Henry
by Chris Ingalls, KING 5
In Partnership With:
Executive Editor: Robert McClure
Data Editor: Jason Alcorn
Executive Producer: Russ Walker, KING 5
Forests and the Economy | May 2015
Environmentalists and the timber industry — once bitter adversaries — are working as allies on forest restoration. Collaborative forest thinning projects aim to fight megafires before they start — but money is scarce and tens of thousands of acres acres in Oregon now face an elevated risk of catastrophic fire. Ben DeJarnette reports for InvestigateWest.
Equity | April 2015
Cash reigns in the Portland housing market. The city faces pressure from a new kind of speculation, as investors buy thousands of homes with cash and long-established protections for bank-financed homebuyers are ignored. Lee van der Voo and James Gordon report for InvestigateWest.
Wealth and Poverty | March 2015
March 2015 marks the anniversary of a bold promise: King County's 10-year plan to end homelessness. Now that the 10-year plan is ending and local homelessness is worse than ever, talk of ending homelessness is being replaced with less-lofty aspirations: making homelessness rare and brief when it does occur.
In collaboration with KUOW this week, we examine the roots of the plan, the challenges it faced, and where community and city leaders think we go from here.
Equal Justice | December 2014
With grand jury reform elsewhere focused on eliminating racial bias and curbing police use of force, Oregon is an outlier: It is one of just 14 states that do not regularly record the citizen grand juries that charge people with felonies.
Almost five years after police killed an unarmed black man in Portland and the Multnomah Co. district attorney petitioned for that grand jury to be recorded, lawmakers in Salem are lining up behind a reform bill to mandate recording statewide, InvestigateWest has learned.
Seafood | December 2014
A struggle in Alaska over shrinking supplies of halibut is threatening the iconic centerpiece fish in favor of cheaper exports, fast-food fillets and fish sticks.
At risk is most of the frozen supply that sustains restaurants, food-service companies and retail stores nationwide, such as Costco and Whole Foods. Lee van der Voo investigates.
Photo: Peter Haley / The News Tribune
Environment | November 2014
It will take hundreds of millions of dollars to clean up the Duwamish River. But how clean is clean? And who decides?
Robert McClure looks at how lobbyists and community groups have squared off over the health of the waterway and its neighborhoods.
Photo: Paul Joseph Brown/ecosystemphoto.com
Trafficking | October 2014
Authorities say organized gangs increasingly are trafficking children for sex in the Northwest, and even cooperating with each other to stymie police.
Meanwhile in Portland, the U.S. Attorney’s Office has become the third most prolific nationally in securing indictments for trafficking children and adults for sex.
Photo: Oregon DOT/Flickr
Minimum Wage | August 2014
"Everyone is aware that passing a $15 an hour minimum wage was historic," an advisor to Mayor Ed Murray and the Seattle City Council told InvestigateWest. "But if we cannot enforce that, we haven't accomplished much."
Based on a review of more than 20,000 wage theft complaints, hundreds of pages of reports and more than a dozen interviews, "Stolen Wages" shines a light on the dark world of pay violations in Seattle and across Washington.
Infrastructure | May 2014
Portable, modular or relocatable classrooms — whatever you call them — are a necessity for cash-strapped schools.
But many portables become permanent fixtures, in place for decades at a time. Costly and insufficient, these aging structures burden the grid, frustrate teachers and administrators and compromise student health.
Environment | April 2014
Energizing our world with wood sounds so natural. And it has quickly become a multibillion-dollar industry as governments including British Columbia and the European Union turn to biomass to replace dirty old coal. Yet what we found when we dug into the coal-vs.-wood debate will surprise you.