Experts in child prostitution "hub" Portland say: Look behind stats for real picture
January 14, 2011
By Nikole Hannah-Jones
PORTLAND -- Mayor Sam Adams stood before reporters and officials in November to decry how Portland has become "stained" as a national hub for juvenile sex trafficking.
As he spoke, aides passed out a news release with a startling statistic. Portland police, it read, see an average of two cases of child sex trafficking each week.
The problem: It wasn't true.
Sgt. Mike Geiger, supervisor of the Portland police sex crimes unit, said police don't track such statistics.
"I am not sure where that is coming from," he said. "That's an unreliable number."
It turns out the belief that Portland is a hub is unreliable, too.
In the span of two short years, the city known as one of the nation's most livable has become a magnet for national media reporting on child sex trafficking. With cameras rolling on 82nd Avenue last year, Dan Rather dubbed the city "Pornland" in a documentary. "Nightline" declared Portland the "epicenter for child prostitution," and "World News With Diane Sawyer" called the city a "hotbed of sex trafficking."
But as hundreds gather in Portland this weekend for the third-annual Northwest Conference Against Trafficking, with talks by U.S. Sen. Ron Wyden and actress Daryl Hannah, an examination by The Oregonian reveals that no one really knows if the problem in Portland is any worse than anywhere else.
While a single case of a child in the sex trade is tragic, little data is kept locally on the depth of the problem, and the figures cited nationally crumble under scrutiny.
"We look at all the numbers that have been put out from various sources," said David Finkelhor, director of the Crimes Against Children Research Center at the University of New Hampshire, "and they are all just extremely speculative."
So how did Portland get a reputation it doesn't deserve?
It started when Portland joined 28 other cities in the FBI's Innocence Lost stings against child sex trafficking in February 2009. Portland was participating for the first time, so when police found seven underage prostitutes -- second only to Seattle's 10 -- it caught the media's attention.
The story proved too good to pass up, and it goes something like this: This picturesque city's rampant strip clubs and permissive attitude toward sex allow wide-eyed suburban girls to be swept into prostitution. Portland's location on the Interstate 5 corridor makes it a prime location to move girls up and down the West Coast.
Fuzzy data and definitions -- lumping under the "trafficked" label not only girls forced into the trade and moved place to place but runaways who sell sex on their own -- fueled the frenzy.
But neither the federal government nor the state of Oregon track child sex trafficking or prostitution. Multnomah County and Portland police don't either. The only local data come from the state Department of Human Services, which tallies Multnomah County youths whom someone reported as being involved in sex for sale.
Even Oregon FBI spokeswoman Beth Anne Steele said the stings were never meant for city-to-city comparisons or to determine the prevalence of trafficking.
For one thing, stings go down differently in different cities. They may last one day in some cities, three in others. Police find girls as part of months-long investigations in some places, and find them online the same night in others.
"We try to stay away from rankings," Steele said. "It is a horrible problem that lots of cities share, and Portland is no worse or better than others."
"In the public eye"
Another FBI sting in October 2009 produced just four girls in Portland. But the storyline stuck, in part because advocates pushed it to draw money and support to their cause. National media arrived, and politicians clamored to do something.
Multnomah County cited the first sting and the city's legal sex industry to land one of three $500,000 federal grants to fight the commercial sexual exploitation of minors, including setting up a system to track cases. In its application, the county said it's "particularly attractive to traffickers," leading to a "particularly high prevalence of sexual exploitation of children."
Multnomah County Commissioner Diane McKeel put sex trafficking at the top of her agenda and was a major force behind a sex trafficking bill by Wyden, expected to pass this year, that would provide up to $7 million to local governments that show they have a problem and an additional $900,000 for a Portland shelter.
The sting prompted Soroptimist International, a women's advocacy organization, to start the annual conference here in 2009, said conference chairwoman Michelle Bart.
"We knew we couldn't raise money if people didn't know about the issue," Bart said. "We are empowering journalists to have a voice and keep this in the public eye."
Bart speaks at length and with passion about young victims forced to sell sex. She was with a group that played the Diane Sawyer piece -- in which a reporter falsely states that 82nd Avenue holds more than 100 strip clubs and massage parlors-- for the board of commissioners last week.
"More than 200,000 youth have been sexually exploited each year," Bart said. "I believe the numbers that have been reported aren't high enough."
That raises perhaps the most frequently cited number around child sex trafficking -- that 200,000 to 300,000 U.S. youths are at risk of sexual exploitation. The U.S. Department of Justice lists the number on its website. Local law enforcement agencies, McKeel's office and others have repeated it, and so have UNICEF, CNN, The Oregonian and the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children have printed it.
The figure is problematic on two fronts. One, advocates often cite it as the number of children in the sex trade -- not just the number at risk of sexual exploitation. Worse, the figure is based on faulty statistics from a 2001 University of Pennsylvania study by Richard Estes and Neil Weiner.
The study took data from an earlier study by Finkelhor, the University of New Hampshire researcher, that counted the number of runaway youths. The Pennsylvania study's authors then came up with a percentage of these kids they believed to be at risk of sexual exploitation of any kind based on interviews with fewer than 300 teens. It was, Finkelhor said, a guess.
This study is also the source for another commonly cited statistic -- that the average age that a child enters prostitution is 12 to 14. Finkelhor has created a fact sheet disputing these and other false child prostitution figures.
"If there are numbers that make it sound large, people want to use it because it is much more problematic to tell people we really don't know," he said. "I don't think there are credible numbers on this." Finkelhor also said no studies have proved a link between Portland's legal sex industry and its illegal one.
Some still stand by the national figures. "I am comfortable with the numbers," McKeel said.
Others have grown wary of the spotlight.
"Portland is not the hub," said Portland police spokeswoman Lt. Kelli Sheffer. Sheffer said that since the rush of national stories, she has "declined (to comment on) any other stories from major publications on trafficking." She said the number of adults arrested on suspicion of trafficking is "very low," though she did not provide statistics despite repeated requests.
Esther Nelson, case manager for exploited youths at the Sexual Assault Resource Center in Portland, said where the city ranks is a good question but shouldn't be the focus. Nelson's organization received some of the grant money Multnomah County won.
"I don't think any city that is looking can't say they have a problem," Nelson said. "But this is a problem (here). It could be anyone's daughter."
Contrast with Seattle
The facts that are known also do little to bolster Portland's image as the epicenter.
Seattle has counted more youths involved in the sex trade than Portland has and found more underage sex workers in the FBI stings. But it hasn't garnered the same attention.
"We're on the same (I-5) corridor," said Sister Susan Francois, anti-trafficking coordinator for the Intercommunity Peace & Justice Center in Seattle. "Whatever problems Portland has, we will also have."
Multnomah County began tracking reports in 2008 of children believed to have been involved in the sex trade -- whether they'd been trafficked, pimped or worked on their own.
Looking at data going back to 2007, officials have identified 165 youths who fit that definition, said Miriam Green, community services manager for the Oregon Department of Human Services in Multnomah County. All the youths came in contact with an authority in the county, but some came from other parts of the state.
By contrast, the city of Seattle tallied 238 children involved in the sex trade in 2007 alone. And in Multnomah County, child abuse calls -- 2,500 a month -- far outnumber those about minors in the sex trade.
But Green offered the county's data with a caveat: "These numbers are only as good as a child (involved in the sex trade) coming to our attention, us recognizing it and making the mandated report," she said.
Steele, the FBI spokeswoman, said that where Portland ranks is irrelevant.
"Anytime you are trafficking in young children, any society should be disturbed by that," she said. "No child should be subjected to this, and no child should ever have to sell themselves on the street."
Meanwhile, a similar FBI sting in November barely made a blip in the media. Law enforcement officers found 16 underage girls in Seattle. In Portland, over three nights, they found three.
Nikole Hannah-Jones is a staff reporter at The Oregonian in Portland. She can be reached at 503-221-4316; email@example.com This story is part of a collaboration by InvestigateWest and The Oregonian.
Editor's note: This story replaces a truncated version that originally appeared on this page.
Minimum Wage | August 2014
"Everyone is aware that passing a $15 an hour minimum wage was historic," an advisor to Mayor Ed Murray and the Seattle City Council told InvestigateWest. "But if we cannot enforce that, we haven't accomplished much."
Based on a review of more than 20,000 wage theft complaints, hundreds of pages of reports and more than a dozen interviews, "Stolen Wages" shines a light on the dark world of pay violations in Seattle and across Washington.
Infrastructure | May 2014
Party politics have thwarted bridge safety improvements, and an investigation drags on to decide how the trucking company, its escort car and the state may share blame. Yet a new mapping tool for truckers may offer hope, Jason Alcorn reports.
Infrastructure | May 2014
Portable, modular or relocatable classrooms — whatever you call them — are a necessity for cash-strapped schools.
But many portables become permanent fixtures, in place for decades at a time. Costly and insufficient, these aging structures burden the grid, frustrate teachers and administrators and compromise student health.
Environment | April 2014
Energizing our world with wood sounds so natural. And it has quickly become a multibillion-dollar industry as governments including British Columbia and the European Union turn to biomass to replace dirty old coal. Yet what we found when we dug into the coal-vs.-wood debate will surprise you.
Public Health | April 2014
We update our 2013 series on Washington’s estimated fish consumption rate with news of a private meeting where Gov. Jay Inslee and his advisers wrestled with how much to protect business versus consumers when it comes to water pollution in the fish we eat.
Consumer Safety | April 2014
Manufacturers put a warning sticker on every ATV sold: The vehicles aren't meant for roads. But a push to allow just that is rolling out across the country. Washington and three other states passed new laws in 2013, among 22 states to allow or expand ATV access to roads since 2004.
Wealth & Poverty | December 2013
It's the unexpected catch in catch-share programs: A federal program that was supposed to help preserve and enhance the fishing economy in Kake, Alaska, has instead helped cause a severe decline. Meanwhile, 50 miles southeast, the town of Petersburg is booming.
The third part in our trilogy of fish stories examines the consequences catch-share policy where it was born, even as the model has been established in 14 other U.S. fisheries, encompassing dozens of species ranging from New England scallops to Pacific sole.
Foster Care | November 2013
State law now allows more kids to stay in foster care for an extra three years — until age 21. But many either refuse the help, or fail to qualify for it.
An investigation by KUOW in collaboration with InvestigateWest looks at why this transition to adulthood is trickier than expected – for foster kids, and for the state.
Public Health | September 2013
Of the roughly 50,000 kids who will attend Seattle schools this fall, nearly 2,000 will hit the books in classrooms within 500 feet of Interstate 5, InvestigateWest has found. This despite a body of evidence dating back decades that highway air pollution can cause lifelong respiratory problems and asthma attacks and boost school absenteeism.
From Seattle to Spokane, what can be done to make sure schools are healthy places for kids?
Photo: John Marshall JHS, 1963. SPSA 108-97.